She is still ostracizing him, but she has at least started talking to him again, though only to repeat that their father is going to kill him. Throughout The Catcher in the Rye, J.D. What was Holdens reply when Phoebe asked him why he got the ax again? She represents the purity and innocence that Holden takes as an almost antidote to the venom that he spits at the world. He is from New York City, where his younger sister, Phoebe, still lives with his parents. Isdentify James Castle. Holden hides in Phoebes closet and before that he talks about his desire. Why did Holden go to Mr. Antolinis house? What happened to James Castle at Elkton Hills? But when Holden tries to ask him about the ducks in the Central Park lagoon, Horwitz unexpectedly becomes angry. a. Allie was Holdens protector, his catcher. What does Holdens red hunting hat symbolize quizlet? It is obvious that Phoebe is an intelligent girl, and Holden's attempts to deceive her end in failure as she realises the truth. used to take Phoebe when she was little. We noticed this when they started Pages 8 ; Ratings 100% (1) 1 out of 1 people found this document helpful; This preview shows page 5 - 8 out of 8 pages.preview shows page 5 - 8 out of 8 pages. What do Holdens answers reveal about him? With his cynical perspective on life Holden finds it hard to connect with people. That the president of the schoolboard and his father had a political disagreement In effect, Allie his ally, his hero abandoned him. Asked by dan c #542269 on 11/8/2017 2:45 PM Last updated by jill d #170087 on 11/8/2017 2:59 PM Answers 1 Add Yours. Part V (Chapter 18-21) Holden's and Phoebe's relationship is a close, loving one, but, ironically, Phoebe is often more mature than Holden, who is years older than she.Certainly, Phoebe is Holden's emotional anchor; for, with his sister there is no need for pretense or embarrassment. What does Holden reveal about Mr. Antolini? Holden concludes his story by refusing to discuss what happened after his day in the park with Phoebe, although he does say that he went home, got sick, and was sent to the rest home from which he now tells his story. I dropped old Phoebes record. In the novel The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Girls are just as smart as boys, even if they are younger. In the scene where Phoebe asked Holden to name something that he liked he had trouble thinking of an answer. Holden decides to go downstairs to the Lavender Room, where the hotel serves drinks and hosts bands. 673 Words. 18-19. Due to his love from Phoebe a complete breakdown by the pond, and from a pointless escape later. The separation of the individual and society is Finally, Phoebe challenges Holden to name any one thing that he really likes, and asks him what he would like to become. Carl left after two martinis and Holden stayed on at the bar. . Why did this depress Holden? Holden is still in the bar where he met Carl Luce, his old academic advisor, as Chapter twenty begins. I honestly think that he likes them because they weren't like other nuns. He starts walking towards Central Park, knowing she will follow him. Why did Holden go home so early (before Wednesday)? Holden is proud of D.B's accomplishments 3. . What was Holden's reaction? 23-24. Buy Study Guide. Catcher In The Rye. Summary: Chapter 12. Holden is only willing to express himself when he is alone, with no one around. Here is an example from page 165: Then something terrible happened just as I got in the park. 21. Holden returns to D.B. Holden becomes very nervous and tells him, Take it easy with that wheel. In a dialogue between Holden and his sister Phoebe, he confesses his fear of people thinking he is queer: 2. The conversation Holden had with his sister Phoebe when he secretly went to visit her was pretty interesting. 5. Phoebe is still angry at Holden, but she follows him to the zoo. Phoebe, for her part, recognizes how tenuous Holden's grasp on reality is. It made me feel not so depressed anymore.. He told her, Im not going away anywhere. 7. Why did Holden leave Mr. Antolinis home before morning? As the reader notices from the very first sentence, Holden makes liberal use of 1950s-era slang (like lousy and swell) and drops curse words (like hell and damn) frequently. Instead, he found his mind wandering to memories of James Castle, a student he had known who had committed suicide. She doesn't have to do much to get Holden to change his mind about going away somewhere. Due to his love from Phoebe a complete breakdown by the pond, and from a pointless escape later. What was Holden's reply when Phoebe asked him why he "got the ax again"? Life is a cycle. A thing I loved is how Mr. Salinger describes Holdens love for his sister. How did Phoebe surprise Holden? What does Holden say about him hating people, such as Ackley and Stradlater? Phillips 1 The Personalities and Emotions of Holden Caufield By: Wendy Phillips (Pearl River Community College) In the novel The Catcher in the Rye J. D. Salinger tells of Holden Caufields struggles in life. "He was two years younger than I was, but he was about fifty more times intelligent". He said it was unfair. Struggling to present a legitimate answer his only response is in regards the lyrics from a record: If a body catch a body comin through the rye. Holden says that he imagines a gigantic field of rye on a cliff full of children playing. Then she says, with all practicality, "Daddy's going to kill you." Although she may be Holden's best friend, Phoebe occasionally demonstrates that she is only 10 years old and unable to understand the depth of Holden's desire. The poem and song "Comin thro' the Rye" is significant to Holden because when Phoebe, his younger sister, asked him what he wanted to do with his life, he replied only with the line, "If a body catch a body comin' through the rye." Suddenly, they hear their parents entering the apartment. 25-26. Holden is a somewhat troubled mind, who has very strong beliefs and thoughts. How did Phoebe surprise Holden? Holden know its crazy (TRC, X), which symbolizes his own struggles. a. Salinger, Holden Caulfield is troubled and needs the help of someone close to him to stop his downward spiral. The broken record is symbolic of both Holden's losing his innocence and his life "shattering" into little pieces.Holden cannot seem to keep his life on a straight path, and the record symbolizes Holden's mistakes at school. What was Holden's reply when Phoebe asked him why he "got the ax again"? After Holden looks for the ducks in Central Park, he starts thinking of Allie being dead and worrying he may be dying. Allie was a brilliant, friendly, red-headed boyaccording to Holden, he was the smartest of the Caulfields. Salinger. Holden wants to call Mr. Antolini, his former teacher at Elkton Hills. Why does Holden idolize Phoebe and Allie so much? Holden sneaked out of the house again as he remembered that he had to wait until Wednesday. In the movie Jamal reminded me of Holden and his girlfriend reminded me Holdens sister, Phoebe. What was Phoebes reaction when she first saw Holden? This preview shows page 8 - 11 out of 22 pages. So why'd he get kicked out, anyway? Holden isnt happy, hes lonesome which would be why hes searching for this sun or happiness (and people to listen to him) but the sun only comes out when it feels like coming out, Which is not very often for Holden and is why he needs to be different and why he is trying to figure out where people go when life gets too hard. Analysis. He said it was unfair. Holden Caulfield chuckles because he knows that was him one day. b. She asked him, "You don't like anything that's happening. When he sees a young boy walking in the street and singing to himself, the sight immediately cheers Holden up: It made me feel better. a. Identify James Castle. On the telephone, Mr. Antolini tells Holden to come right over if he wants. Holden wants to protect Phoebe just as Ally did for him. Holden says that he hardly knew James, but he feels an apparent closeness, perhaps symbolized by the fact that Castle died in Holden's sweater. Click to see full answer. Phoebe is asleep in D.B. After some thought Holden tells her that he wants to be the catcher in the rye. This takes place at the beginning of the story. In this manner, who are Holden's siblings? And mean guys. Holden does not like what lawyers do because he feels like Lawyers are alright, I guess but it doesn't appeal to me", I said. As he puts on a new shirt, he considers calling his little sister, Phoebe, whom he cares about very much. In the scene where Phoebe asked Holden to name something that he liked he had trouble thinking of an answer. He overcomes his alienation with Holden also has a deceased younger brother, Allie, and an older brother, D.B. Phoebe is the only person Holder trusts. Filed Under: Essays. That he has always been depressed. How does Holden feel physically while he talks to Mr. Antolini? After going into the living room to fetch a cigarette from a small box on the table, Holden reenters Phoebe s room. Neither could Holden save Allie. 1. When the main character Phoebe asks why he "got the ax again," she refers to learning that Holden has been kicked out of yet another school. I think, he believes the opposite because he is deathly serious about life, and he doesnt accept the rules set before him by adults. It symbolizes the confidence, self esteem, and comfort in who someone is. Holden returns to D.B. Holden , Phoebe and Allie are siblings who are in the novel `` The Catcher In the Rye . '' Holden is upset by the harsh swear word written on the wall of the museum because it is violating a place that he values as a childs place. Holden , Phoebe and Allie are siblings who are in the novel `` The Catcher In the Rye . '' By J. D. Salinger. Holden is still in the bar where he met Carl Luce, his old academic advisor, as Chapter twenty begins. 5. What was Holden's reply when Phoebe asked him why he "got the ax again"? Get link; Facebook; Twitter; Pinterest; Email; Other Apps - Identify James Castle. Holden buys Phoebe a ticket for the carousel and watches her ride. Carl was very critical of Holden and he acted very superior. Holden Caulfield couldnt help, but to be flattered by the ways of this little boy. Why does Holden give Phoebe his hunting cap? He waits for Phoebe, who comes to meet him with a suitcase. Phoebe tells Holden she is going with him, but he tells her she cannot go. b. What advice did Mr. Antolini give Holden? In talking with her parents how does Phoebe "sound" like Holden? Holdens little sister Phoebe Caulfield is an important element and is going to change things for him. In this way, what is Holden's relationship with Phoebe? What is Holdens mistake regarding the catcher in the rye? Holden's own language is often salty, and Phoebe asked him to stop cursing when he visited her in the apartment, but he finds this word especially abhorrent and does not use it around his sister. 's room. Holden is so lonesome and depressed that he cries in chapter 20. While riding the carousal, Phoebe forgives Holden. Phoebe still isnt talking to Holden, but he can tell she isnt as mad at him as she was before. 3. Why did Holden hate Pencey Prep? Summary: Holden comes back to Phoebes room with cigarettes and is able to have her listen to him. 5. Chapters 22-26 1. Mental health is our emotional, psychological, and social well-being. It seems Holden realized at this moment, the carousel was like life. The scene in which Holden watches Phoebe sleep and reads through her notebooks is one of the most famous in the book, one of the few moments of respite Holden finds from the brutality of the outside world. Holden tells Phoebe it is okay with him if she ditches the rest of the school day, and comes with him to the Zoo. 2. The author shows the reader Holdens keen wits; Holdens sensitivity; childishness, kindness; bravery, strengths and weaknesses. 1. How did Holdens feelings for Sally change from the beginning of the date to the end? She is more mature than Holden and he is six years older than her. 2. What was Holdens reply when Phoebe asked him why he got the ax again? This book has sold more than 65 million copies, and continues to hold great appeal and cultural importance due to how it approaches the topic of adolescence, as well as the loss of innocence. Can you find a few things in the chapter leading up to him crying that highlight how he is alienated and alone? 20. What does Phoebe ask Holden to name? The book begins The significance of James Castle's brave though ill-considered and tragic death is that it strikes home, once more, Holden's concern about protecting innocence. What was Holden's reply when Phoebe asked him why he "got the ax again"? This same idea appears again during a conversation between him, and his little sister Phoebe. Phoebe has coped with Allies death in a healthy way as Holden has not. 5. Why did Holden leave Mr. Antolini's home before morning? Holdens red hunting hat is a symbol of his alienation. Holden idolizes his younger brother and sister because he views them as idealized versions of himself . Her sanity and naturalness restores confidence of society in Holder. He sits down at D.B. 5. The Catcher in the Rye Summary and Analysis of Chapters 21-26. When I asked him, he said right before he was admitted into the institution, watching Phoebe ride a carousel was what made him truly happy. 2. Phoebes response to Holden tells us that he has always been unsatisfied. What happened to the boys who were involved? There were similarities within the scenes and in the characters. What Was Holden's Reply When Phoebe Asked Him. The voice is characterized by Holdens colloquial and frank use of language. Holden is only willing to express himself when he is alone, with no one around. 6. Holden clearly loves his brother. When they stop at a red light, Ernie starts caressing the steering wheel lovingly. This same idea appears again during a conversation between him, and his little sister Phoebe. Analysis. He has always been unhappy and he doesnt put the effort to change that. 19. He said it was unfair, that the teachers just didnt like him and were out to get him. After his sister Phoebe asked him what he wanted to be his response was, Anyway, I keep picturing all these little kids playing some game in this big field of rye and all. She has the radio on, and they dance. Chapters 20-23. b. 2. "All I need is an audience. Phoebe Holden. Why did Holden go to Mr. Antolinis house? Phoebe is the only person Holder trusts. Get link; Facebook; Twitter; Pinterest; Email; Other Apps - May 06, 2022 2 Post a Comment Read more What Is the Best Beautyrest Mattress to Buy. Phoebe asked Holden if he wants to be a lawyer and Holden wants to tell Phoebe how Phony lawyer are to him. The Catcher in the Rye is a book about a cynical, confused, depressed teenager, Holden Caulfied, by J. D. Salinger, an American author, published in 1951. See answer (1) Best Answer. 3. 9. 6. Holden lights a cigarette, and Phoebe explains how she can fake a fever. Summary and Analysis Chapter 23. 4. Suddenly, they hear their parents entering the apartment. (207) At the end of the book, Holden seems to be much more mature. Analysis: Chapters 2123. Holden idolizes his younger brother and sister because he views them as idealized versions of himself . This can be a huge factor in Holdens mental health. Carl was very critical of Holden and he acted very superior. 3. Phoebes response to Holden tells us that he has always been unsatisfied. Holden returns home, where he is very quiet so as not to awake his parents. Identify James Castle. He has always been unhappy and he doesnt put the effort to change that. Why did Holden go to Mr. Antolini's house? This scene suggests that Holden clearly has a fascination with death. Once Holden comes back to Phoebe's room, she tries to ignore him. While Phoebe showed concern for him, she somehow got mad and asked him what would become of him, or what would he like to be when he got older. Her sanity and naturalness restores confidence of society in Holder. His troubles cloud his mind and make it difficult for him to succeed in school, and to operate in the real world. 3. What happened on Veterans Day? The teachers just didn't like him and were out to get him. I changed my mind. Why or why not? Holden feels deeply drawn to children. What was Holden's reply when Phoebe asked him why he "got the ax again"? The Catcher in the Rye How did Phoebe surprise holden What was his reaction? She at once finds out that Holden has been restricted from his school and even guesses about him failing all exams. Holden wears the red hunting What does Phoebe do that makes Holden cry? Phoebe refuses to go back to school or take a walk with Holden. Holden treats Phoebe with more respect and kindness than he treats any other character in the story. This preview shows page 8 - 11 out of 22 pages. But independent Phoebe is mature beyond her years and does not need saving. Analysis. 1. The hat represents individuality and uniqueness. Why? She has the radio on, and they dance. Analysis. She is still ostracizing him, but she has at least started talking to him again, though only to repeat that their father is going to kill him. He said the work was too hard, because he had not been adequately prepared at the last school. Click to see full answer. What was Holden's reaction? Chapter 2, pg 8: Dr. Thurmer say to Holden. Why did Holden go to Mr. Antolini's house? This makes him cry. Holden takes a cab to a Greenwich Village nightclub called Ernies, a spot he used to frequent with D. B. 25-26. How is she similar to and/or different from her brothers, according to Holdens description of her? When Phoebe places Holden's red hunting hat on his head near the end of the novel, this action symbolizes that she doesnt accept him. 4. Phoebe explains that Holden has misunderstood the song. 4 pages, 1507 words. This enrages him. He said it was unfair and that the teachers just didn't like him and were out to get him. The hat represents individuality and uniqueness. Holden needs Phoebe at the museum and Phoebe sees holding in caring open his old Suitcase and holding Zees for a beer at the able to pick that up and then she started talking to him and she was kind of out of breath but Holden are use with Phoebe because she packed her clothes and she wanted to go with holding a. Catcher in the Rye: Chapters 22-26. This scene suggests that Holden clearly has a fascination with death. Each time Holden tries to steer the conversation away from his actions, Phoebe draws him back in. A million reasons why. 12) In your own words, summarize Holdens description of what it is like to dance with a really good dance partner. But Allie died and could not save Holden from his abusers. 3. Phoebe and Holden are different in this way that she is innocent and is growing up where as he isnt innocent and isnt growing up. Phoebe makes him realize he has two solutions, to unbreak the change or commit suicide. He assures her he's going to be fine on his ranch in Colorado, and harasses her about a stupid haircut somebody gave her. Why did Holden fail his speech class? That he has always been depressed. Wiki User. Positive relationships in The Catcher in the Rye. Phoebe also knows how to save her brother at some points in the story. 8. As he says, adults look lousy when sleeping, but kids look all right.. Are you surprised by his response? Holden lights a cigarette, and Phoebe explains how she can fake a fever. As Holden was talking with Phoebe at the house, he offers her the hat and makes her keep it. Salingers book The Catcher in the Rye holds a different relationship with his sister Phoebe than any other character in the book. Click to see full answer. You never saw so many mean guys in your life." Holden Caulfield chuckles because he knows that was him one day. After meandering silently through the zoo, Holden and Phoebe start to walk toward a large carousel where Holden, Allie, and D.B. He said the work was too hard because he had not been adequately prepared at the last school. Dr. Thurmer says it but Holden doesnt agree him, he never believes that life is a game. What was Holdens reply when Phoebe asked him why he got the ax again? answer choices . 3. Holden clearly loves his brother. Holden isn't used to kindness. Summary: Chapter 26. After going into the living room to fetch a cigarette from a small box on the table, Holden reenters Phoebe s room. 4. What is his response? Chapter 21. Unlike her parents, she knows he is struggling, and she simply wants to be there for him. 's room, now inhabited by Phoebe. She gets worried about him and says daddys going to kill for a while. 18. 23. His whole world is built around pessimistic negativity about human nature. 20-22. 28 2009 CITR Constructed Response: Chapter 23 Holden Caulfield the main character from J.D. How is she similar to and/or different from her brothers, according to Holdens description of her? It was one of the worst schools I ever went to. The Catcher in the Rye is a novel by J.D. Phoebe doesn't respond for a long time. He proceeds to get drunk and calls Sally at about 1:00 in the morning. 13) Why is Holden sorry for having kidded Old Marty? Copy. Holden truly admires the personality Allie had a.) It was full of phonies. After his sister Phoebe asked him what he wanted to be his response was, Anyway, I keep picturing A million reasons, Holden repliesmostly, everyone there was mean and phony. 11) Compare Phoebe with both Holden and Allie. Chapter 24 . It upsets him that innocent children must see such a thing. What was Holden's reply when Phoebe asked him why he got the ax again? The novel's narrator and protagonist, Holden is a high school junior who has flunked out of prep school several times. One that is very, very rare. It symbolizes the confidence, self esteem, and comfort in who someone is. One may also ask, what Phoebe is a foil character in this book because she makes Holden seem that much more immature because of her level of maturity at such a young age. He proceeds to get drunk and calls Sally at about 1:00 in the morning. Phoebe is the only person who Holden needs 2. Holden's sister Phoebe, has a special impact on Holden. ". Allie Caulfield - Holden's younger brother. 6. Phoebe Caulfield. What advice did Mr. Antolini give Holden? Holdens red hunting hat is one of the main symbols in the book, The Catcher in the Rye. 5. shs crowning him with the hat to forever ostracize him . Instead, he found his mind wandering to memories of James Castle, a student he had known who had committed suicide. Phoebe concludes that he hates everything, and asks him to name one thing he likes. What do Holden and Phoebe exchange before he leaves for Mr. Antolinis? Carl left after two martinis and Holden stayed on at the bar. Throughout the book, when mentioning the museum, he always remembers how he loved going there as a child and being innocent. When Holden says he wants to move west, he is not actually meaning that he will move west. What words does Holden Caulfield use a lot? Frustrated she reminds him that Allie is dead and goes on to ask Holden what he wants to do in life. What is Phoebes reaction to Holdens expulsion from Pencey Prep? What was Holdens reply when Phoebe asked him why he got the ax again? 3. 's room, now inhabited by Phoebe. He said the way she spun around and around coming back each time. Holden decides to go visit Phoebe, and he buys her the record "Little Shirley Beans" as a gift. 20-22. 23-24. Phoebe told him that she wanted to go along with him, but he denies her of this because of his growing responsibility and metamorphosis as an adult. Family A. As he puts on a new shirt, he considers calling his little sister, Phoebe, whom he cares about very much. After reading The Catcher in the Rye and watching the movie Finding Forrester, I noticed many similarities. He explains how terrible it is to be at his school and how he hates it so much. 4. Holden decides to go downstairs to the Lavender Room, where the hotel serves drinks and hosts bands. 2010-10-26 22:53:56. Why does Holden idolize Phoebe and Allie so much? 18-19. He said the work was too hard because he had not been adequately prepared at the last school. Holden's gift of the hunting hat to Phoebe is a significant event, for it is one of Holden's few meaningful possessions. So he said that he wanted to be a catcher in the rye, who would rescue those would fall off the cliff. Holden wanted to pass the hunting cap to Phoebe because he believes that it had protected him from the world, and hopes that the hat will do the same to Phoebe.Holden gives the hat to Phoebe because he believes the hat will keep Phoebes innocence pristine.. Why does Holden wear a red hunting hat? 4. Later in the book, Holden hires an obviously gay cab driver named Ernie. Identify James Castle. What does Holden give to Phoebe? The one person he considers pure and good extends further kindness to Holden. He said the work was too hard, because he had not been adequately prepared at the last school. Summary and Analysis Chapter 23. "The only thing Holden could think of were the nuns. They have some conversations and right during that, their psrents return home. When it starts to rain, Phoebe puts the red hunting hat on Holden's head. This analogy epitomizes the only future Holder can see for himself. 12) In your own words, summarize Holdens description of what it is like to dance with a really good dance partner. Why did Holden leave Mr. Antolini's home before morning? A feminist might look at this as Holden doesn't know himself but the girl who is the closest to him knows him better. The teachers just didn't like him and were out to get him. Perhaps the cap symbolizes Holdens fading childhood innocence or it could symbolize the protection of childhood innocence. What was her reaction when she found out that he had been expelled? On the telephone, Mr. Antolini tells Holden to come right over if he wants. 22. His cab driver is named Horwitz, and Holden takes a liking to him.